Zannatul Firdaus

Fellow, Dismislab
Old images, videos used in recent news without context

Old images, videos used in recent news without context

Zannatul Firdaus

Fellow, Dismislab

A photograph of a collapsed building in Gaza was used in a report about Israeli attacks in Lebanon. A video report on a helicopter accident in Greece showed footage from three different incidents. Such examples of using old or unrelated images and videos by news outlets are becoming increasingly common in Bangladesh. Also, the outlets fail to mention anywhere in the captions or inside the story that the images or footage were unrelated to the events being reported. As a result, readers and viewers may find it difficult to understand the actual context of the visuals.

Dismislab fact-checked 13 instances of old or unrelated images and footage used in reports and videos about recent events in Bangladeshi news media over a two-month period, from August 10 to October 10. 

Using file photographs or footage in news reports is not new, nor is it prohibited under international journalistic standards. However, when images or videos from previous or unrelated events are used, their context must be clearly explained so that readers and viewers are not misled. Bangladeshi news outlets are not adhering to this guideline.

3 old footage clips in one report on helicopter accident in Greece

A Dismislab report published on August 24 found that Jamuna TV had published a video on its YouTube channel on August 18 about a helicopter accident in Greece. The video contained four footage clips, three of which were old and related to different incidents. However, none of the clips was identified as archival or old footage.

Screenshot of the report published by Jugantor (left) and the report published by CNN US (right).

The first clip showed a helicopter carrying five people crashing into the sea at Pearl Harbor in Hawaii, United States, in 2016. The second showed an Apache helicopter crashing during a training exercise in Texas, United States, on August 13, 2026, killing two military personnel. Another clip showed two firefighting helicopters colliding while battling wildfires in Greece. Two military personnel were killed in that incident.

Photograph of collapsed building in Gaza used in report on attacks in Lebanon

According to Lebanon’s Ministry of Public Health, at least 12 people, including two children, were killed in Israeli attacks in Lebanon on September 7, 2026. On September 8, an official Facebook page of DBC News published a photo card stating, “Nearly 800 children killed and 360,000 children displaced in Israeli attacks in Lebanon.”

Screenshot of DBC News’s photo card (left) and The Guardian’s report (right).

A Dismislab report published on September 9 found that the photograph used in the card was not from Lebanon. It showed a building in Beit Lahia, Gaza, that had collapsed following an Israeli attack on October 29, 2024. The same photograph had also appeared in reports published by the British media outlets Middle East Eye and The Guardian.

Same old photograph used in reports on 2 incidents in Saudi Arabia

On August 9, 2026, a fire at a furniture factory in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, killed 16 Bangladeshi nationals. In another incident, an attack targeted a Saudi Aramco oil facility in the city of Jizan on September 7. Several news outlets in Bangladesh and India used a photograph from an unrelated incident while reporting on these two events.

A Dismislab report published on September 9 found that the photograph showed a fire at a Saudi Aramco petroleum storage facility in Jeddah following a Houthi attack on March 25, 2022. The image, taken nearly four and a half years earlier, was subsequently used by 17 Bangladeshi news outlets in reports about the fire at the furniture factory in Riyadh. These included Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha (BSS), The Business Standard, The Financial Express, Bangladesh Pratidin and DBC News, among others.

Irrelevant photographs used in reports by Bangladesh Pratidin and NDTV, alongside the photograph used in Al Jazeera’s report.

The same photograph was also used by the daily Manabkantha in a report on the attack on the Aramco oil facility in Jizan. The daily Manabzamin published a Facebook photo card using the same image.

2007 photograph used in report on ferry sinking in Indonesia

On September 13, 2026, a ferry named Virgo Transport 8, carrying 243 people, sank after departing from Surabaya in East Java province, Indonesia.

A Dismislab report published on September 14 found that News24, Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha (BSS) and Barta24 had used a photograph from a 2007 ferry disaster while reporting on the sinking on September 13. On January 1 of that year, a ferry carrying around 600 passengers sank off the coast of Java due to adverse weather conditions.

Screenshot of Bangladesh Sangbad Sangstha’s report (left) and the photograph used in an AFP report published on January 2, 2007 (right).

Old photograph from Yemen used in report on attack on Saudi Airbase

Several international media outlets published reports about a Houthi attack on Saudi Arabia’s King Khalid Air Base on September 14. Dismislab’s fact-check found that several Bangladeshi news outlets had used an old photograph in their reports and photo cards about the incident.

Screenshot of The Ittefaq’s report (left) and an Al Jazeera report published in 2015 (right).

The photograph used in reports by the daily Manabzamin, ATN News and the daily Ittefaq showed the aftermath of an airstrike by the Saudi-led coalition in Sana’a, the capital of Yemen, more than 11 years earlier.

Footage from unrelated incident used in report on student protests in France

A Dismislab report published on October 6 found that Dhaka Tribune had published a video report claiming to show recent student protests in France. The video contained four footage clips, at least three of which were old or related to different incidents.

According to reports by Euronews, the fact-checking organisation MISBAR and the Turkish news outlet Yeni Safak, the first two clips in the report published on October 5 showed protests in Paris in December 2022 against the fatal shooting of members of the Kurdish community. The fourth clip used in the report showed an incident in France in 2023 in which a school bus caught fire.

Scenes used in Dhaka Tribune’s video report (left) and a screenshot of MISBAR’s fact-checking report (right).

In addition, Dismislab identified several other instances (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6) in which news outlets used old photographs and videos.

Captions say only ‘collected,’ without providing actual context

International news outlets provide the source and context when using old photographs in their reports. For example, when Al Jazeera uses a file photograph, its captions explain the context of the image. This helps readers understand that the photograph is not from the recent event being reported.

File photograph used in Al Jazeera’s report and its context.

In Bangladeshi news outlets, however, photographs are often accompanied only by the word “Collected.” An example appeared in a report and Facebook photo card published by DBC News on October 4 about an attack on a tanker in the Strait of Hormuz. The report used a photograph of an oil tanker that caught fire following an attack in the Gulf of Oman nearly seven years earlier. Neither the photograph’s caption nor the report mentioned this information or provided its context. As a result, readers could get the impression that the photograph showed the attack on October 4.

What do journalistic guidelines say about using old images and videos?

The more important question is not whether old photographs or videos can be used in news reports, but how they are presented and whether their use misleads readers or viewers.

The BBC’s editorial guidelines state that old or archival material may be used. However, it must not be presented in a way that gives viewers a misleading impression of an event, situation or subject depicted in the footage. When planning to reuse or re-edit previously published editorial material, it is important to consider that the material may have become inaccurate or outdated. Therefore, viewers must be clearly informed, where necessary, that the material has been taken from the archive.

In other words, using old visuals is not itself the main problem. What matters is the context in which they are used and the impression created by their presentation. Simply labelling old footage as “archive” or “file footage” may not be sufficient; the time and event the footage actually depicts must also be clearly specified. Otherwise, viewers may be misled. It is therefore essential to clearly identify the actual source and context of the footage.

What news outlets say about use of old images and videos

To understand why irrelevant old images are being published in reports about recent events, Dismislab contacted several Bangladeshi news outlets.

Reaz  Ahmad, editor of Dhaka Tribune, said that such lapses sometimes occur in the news outlet’s new media content or digital production department.

Asked whether the outlet had any guidelines on the use of old photographs or unrelated videos, he said, “Under our news presentation guidelines, the irrelevant use of old photographs is prohibited. File photographs may be used where applicable, but they must be specific and accompanied by a disclaimer so that readers and viewers are not misled in any way.”

Md Tanzir Rahman Bhuiyan, head of the online department at The Business Standard, said that the use of irrelevant old photographs or videos in news reports is strictly prohibited.

“Photographs or videos must always be relevant. If relevant photographs or videos are unavailable, relevant symbolic images or illustrations should be used instead.”

He believes that reducing the use of old photographs or videos unrelated to news reports requires more than simply cautioning journalists. Clear editorial guidelines, training and accountability are also necessary.

Rajib Nandy, associate professor in the Department of Communication and Journalism at the University of Chittagong and a researcher on new media, believes that old photographs are often used in online journalism because of pressure to publish news quickly, the absence of photographers at the scene, limitations in managing their own photographic archives or a lack of interest in doing so, and staff shortages.

A photograph may be used if it is relevant to the report. The condition is that if the photograph is old or relates to another event, this must be clearly stated in the caption.

“In journalism, the purpose of a photograph is not merely to make news visible, but to present reality accurately. Using an old photograph is not unethical. What matters most is whether readers are getting an accurate understanding of the actual event from the photograph.”

Rajib Nandy also believes that readers can easily be misled if the source of an old photograph is not mentioned in its caption. In his words, “In news reports, photographs often serve as visual evidence of an event for readers. Particularly online, many people form their initial understanding of an event simply by looking at the headline and photograph. An incorrect photograph can sometimes make even an accurate news report misleading.”

Noting that many Bangladeshi news outlets tend to consider their responsibility fulfilled by writing only “Collected” or “Old photograph” in captions, he said, “Mentioning the source of a photograph is not merely a matter of giving credit to the photographer; it is also part of a news outlet’s fact-checking and accountability.”